Immediately, after checking into a hotel, many visitors wanted to get a general sense of the city before they began sightseeing. The most popular method was to find a high point from which to look down panoramically over Kyoto, identifying key temples and shrines, mapping out prospective itineraries with the eye, and evaluating the beauty of the scene.
Kyoto’s basin-like topography (displayed here using a map of the city from c.1890), in which the city gradually declines from the northern, eastern and western hills, meant that travellers found themselves unable to visual apprehend the cityscape upon arrival in the south, whether alighting at the Fushimi riverboat wharf or, from 1877, coming by train to Shichijō railway station. Conveniently, however, that same natural topography afforded a number of excellent viewing platforms in the Higashiyama area, the eastern hills that provided the location for some of the earliest Western-style hotels. Thus Kyoto, at least in the early to mid-Meiji period, compared positively to Tokyo, a comparatively flat city of low-rise buildings, where travellers often complained about the difficulty of achieving a bird’s eye view: “I have vainly hunted,” wrote Alexander Graf von Hübner, “for some culminating spot from whence one could look down on this immense town [Tokyo] as a whole. The lay of the ground and the absence of high towers prevent you seeing anything but a small portion of it at any one time” (1874, 408).
Views of Kyoto from the eastern hills were not outside the city's aesthetic geography — the scenery from the rokuami restaurants and tea houses of Anyōji temple was extolled in Edo-period guides. But, in contrast to views of Higashiyama, they were not part of the traditional pictorial lexicon, as evidenced in both meisho-zue (名所図会) guidebooks like Karaku meishō-zue Higashiyama no bu (花洛名勝図会東山之部, 1864) and Yamamoto Kakuma's (山本覚馬) English-language Celebrated Places (1873).
This began to change with the advent of modern tourism, as guidebooks directed tourists to key viewpoints in the eastern hills, from which panoramas of the city were framed in word-pictures, sketches, paintings and photographs, before being reproduced in tourist literature for other potential visitors to see (cf. Takagi 2020). Private tourism operators, particularly the Higashiyama hotels with balconies and veranda, promoted themselves using views in advertising. Also, from the 1910s, views were marketed to foreign visitors by government agencies: at first, Japan Government Railways and Japan Tourist Bureau, then from 1930, the Bureau of Tourist Industry and the Kyoto City Tourism Bureau.
“The best way to begin seeing Kioto is to ascend the Maruyama — a beautiful wooden hill, which rises about 500ft, directly at the back of the city, and commands a magnificent view of the entire plain in which it is situated. The city is stretched out like a map at our feet, and we can discern with a glass all the principle temples, the Imperial Palace and gardens, and other objects of note. In front is the road by which we travelled from Osaka; behind is that leading to Lake Biwah, which we hope yet to travel, and all around are wooded hills and fertile plains, bright with sunshine.”
“The Capital of the Mikado,” Times (August 18 1876), 10
“We climbed to the summit just above us [at Chion-in] and cast our admiring gaze over this vast edifice and the mountain bound city of Kioto, which the setting sun was making glorious with its soft, quiet light, and as we gazed, the thoughts would fill the mind that this was the East, the far Orient, and that it was beyond the power of man to picture from our western homes a scene more fair.”
M.B. Cook, Japan: A Sailor’s Visit to the Island Empire (New York: John B. Alden, 1891), 115
Views of Kyoto from the east, in Segawa Mitsuyuki (瀬川光行), Nihon no Meishō (日本之名勝) [Famous places in Japan] (Shiden Hensan Sho, 1900). National Diet Library Digital Collection (403-76)
The evaluations made by tourists as they looked down on the city were, generally, positive.
But some travellers found the wide perspective of the panorama offered a different kind of view. For example, British traveller A.M. Thompson, arriving soon after the close of the Russo-Japanese War, painted a bleak picture of exploited labour, working all hours to produce souvenirs for the tourist trade, from “the luxurious seclusion of the Miyako Hotel”: “The sonorous charm of the grasshopper’s never-ending song took on a note of sadness when I looked down on the lights still burning in the picturesque workshops of the poetic writers’ raptures” (1911, 57).
Into the 1930s, the recording of elevated views became increasingly restricted, due to security concerns. American J. Russel Wait, touring Japan in 1939 by invitation from the Japan Foreign Trade Federation, took the cablecar to the top of Mt. Hiei to find “a reall [sic.] superb view for many miles” and notices “posted all about […] — NO PICTURES, SURVEYING OR SKETCHING ON ANY ELEVATED POINT MORE THAN 100 METERS” (1940, 106).
Follow the links below to find out more about some of the most popular viewpoints in Kyoto from the 1870s to the 1930s.